What-If

Explore realistic options before choosing a path.

What-If

Objective

To help individuals and teams generate multiple workable options by testing different possibilities in a structured and practical way.

Problem Statement

When facing a challenge, people often jump too quickly to the first solution that seems reasonable.

This can limit creativity, narrow judgement, and make teams overlook better alternatives. In many situations, the problem is not a lack of ideas, but a lack of viable options that have been properly explored.

Without generating and comparing different possibilities, decision quality can suffer.

Solution Provided

Generate Viable Options is a physical thinking activity where participants explore different “what if” possibilities and combine them into workable options.

Using reusable game elements, players test alternative directions, constraints, and choices to build several realistic paths forward. Instead of settling on one immediate answer, they create and compare multiple options before deciding.

This helps make thinking broader, more practical, and more flexible.

The Science

This activity is grounded in research on decision-making and problem solving.

  • Divergent thinking – Exploring multiple possibilities improves the quality and range of ideas
  • Option generation – Better decisions come from comparing several workable paths, not just one
  • Cognitive flexibility – Considering alternatives strengthens adaptability and judgement

These insights show that strong thinking is not only about finding an answer. It is also about creating better options to choose from.

Generate Viable Options helps individuals and teams build that ability through repeated practice.

Time Commitment

10–15 minutes.

Facilitation Level

Light

  1. Whatthis fixes

You jump to the first solution without exploring better options. 

Explore possibilities beyond current reality to expand thinking. 

 

  1. How this works

You take a problem and build multiple possible solutions using structured prompts and constraints. 

Each round follows: 

Scenario → What If → Constraints → Options → Trade-off → Risk → Select 

You do not settle on one idea early. 

You generate, test, and compare multiple workable options before choosing. 

Total time: 5–10 minutes per round 

 

  1. When to use
  • When decisions feel rushed 
  • When only one solution is being considered 
  • When trade-offs are unclear 
  • When teams need better decision quality 
  • When exploring multiple paths is critical 

 

  1. What you get
  • Multiple structured solution options 
  • Clear understanding of constraints 
  • Explicit trade-offs for each option 
  • Identified risks before execution 
  • A stronger, more informed decision 

 

  1. Whatyou’llnotice 
  • Better quality decisions 
  • Less bias toward the first idea 
  • Clearer understanding of trade-offs 
  • More confidence in chosen direction 

 

  1. Why this works

Better decisions come from comparing viable options, not picking quickly. 

  • Option generation: More choices improve decision quality 
  • Constraint thinking: Real-world limits make ideas practical 
  • Trade-off clarity: Decisions improve when priorities are explicit 
  • Risk awareness: Stress-testing prevents weak choices 

 

⚠️ PAGE BREAK 

 

  1. What you need
  2. Board

Not required 

 

  1. Cards

1. Scenario Cards 

  • Define the problem 
  • Use 1 card per round 

 

2. What If Cards 

  • Open new directions 
  • Used to generate possibilities 

 

3. Constraint Cards 

  • Add real-world limits 
  • Must be applied to all options 

 

4. Trade-off Cards 

  • Force a clear choice between priorities 
  • Used to define what you are choosing over something else 

 

5. Risk Cards 

  • Used to stress-test options 
  • Identify what could fail 

 

6. Voting Cards 

  • Used to select the strongest option 

 

Card Usage Rules 

  • Place 1 Scenario Card (Step 1) 
  • Give each team: 
  • 2 What If Cards 
  • 2 Constraint Cards 
  • 1 Trade-off Card 
  • 1 Risk Card 
  • Use all assigned cards 
  • Do not skip any layer 

 

  1. Inputs

Not required (all inputs come from cards) 

 

  1. Roles

Team mode (recommended): 

  • Participants → generate and evaluate options 
  • Optional facilitator → manages time and flow 

Individual mode: 

  • Single player runs through all steps 

 

  1. Materials
  • Scenario Cards 
  • What If Cards 
  • Constraint Cards 
  • Trade-off Cards 
  • Risk Cards 
  • Voting Cards 
  • Blank cards or paper 
  • Pen or marker 

 

  1. Steps

 

Step 1 - Understand the scenario (30–60 seconds) 

Pick 1 Scenario Card. 

Place it in the centre. 

Read it clearly. 

 

Step 2 - Explore possibilities (1–2 minutes) 

Use both What If Cards. 

Generate directions based on them. 

Do not evaluate yet. 

 

Step 3 - Apply constraints (1 minute) 

Use both Constraint Cards. 

Ensure all options must work within these limits. 

Do not ignore constraints. 

 

Step 4 - Build options (1–2 minutes) 

Create at least 2 options: 

  • Option A 
  • Option B 

Use this format: 

“We will ___ + ___ under ___ constraint, 

choosing ___ over ___” 

Keep options realistic. 

 

Step 5 - Declare the trade-off (30–60 seconds) 

Use the Trade-off Card. 

State clearly what you are prioritising. 

Example: speed over quality. 

 

Step 6 - Stress test (1 minute) 

Use the Risk Card. 

Identify what could fail in each option. 

Do not skip this step. 

 

Step 7 - Present (1–2 minutes) 

Share: 

  • Options 
  • Trade-off 
  • Risk 

Keep it clear and concise. 

 

Step 8 - Vote (1 minute) 

Use Voting Cards to select: 

  • Most Viable 
  • Most Strategic 
  • Most Creative 

Choose the strongest option. 

 

  1. Output / Takeaways
  • Multiple tested solution options 
  • Clear trade-offs for each option 
  • Identified risks before execution 
  • A selected, well-evaluated direction 

 

  1. Important rules
  • Do not stop at one option 
  • Do not ignore constraints 
  • Always define the trade-off 
  • Always identify risk 
  • Focus on viable options, not perfect ones 

 

  1. Example

Context: 

Scenario → Team is missing deadlines 

 

Step 2: 

What If → Reduce scope, change ownership 

 

Step 3: 

Constraints → No extra budget, fixed deadline 

 

Step 4: 

Option → 

Reduce scope + assign clear ownership under fixed deadline, 

choosing speed over quality 

 

Step 5: 

Trade-off → Speed over quality 

 

Step 6: 

Risk → Quality may drop 

 

Step 8: 

Selected as most viable 

 

After: 

A realistic and testable option is chosen. 

 

Open up options. 

Test reality. 

Build better decisions. 

Planning to run this game/activity? Listen to the audio instructions below for a smooth and effective session.

MIndn
Execution must be smooth. Not chaotic or stressful.
Built by Witmer.