Break the Frame

Find newer, fresher ideas to solve a stuck problem.

Break the Frame

What this fixes

Teams often get stuck discussing the same problem and recycling the same ideas. The issue usually isn’t a lack of ideas - it’s that everyone is looking at the problem from the same angle. 

This activity forces the team to view the problem through very different eyes and uncover options that their original thinking would never have reached. 

How this works

Imagine the team has spent three meetings discussing the same problem, and nothing genuinely new is emerging. 

First, everyone privately writes the solution they’d choose right now. Then the team tackles the problem through a series of different viewpoints - some familiar, some unexpected. As new options emerge, they’re captured on the board. 

At the end, the team compares those options with where they started. The question is simple: which ideas would never have appeared from the team’s original point of view? 

Team: one person acts as the facilitator - they run the activity using the Facilitator Guide while everyone else takes part. 

Time required

Team ✓ · About 35–45 minutes (two or three viewpoints), with a facilitator. For a deeper session, run more viewpoints - about 60–90 minutes.  

The time required is indicative and will depend on the nature of the problem and the size of the team. 

The facilitator should read the short facilitation guide first - about 10 minutes. It’s a downloadable PDF on this page. 

When to use

Use it whenever the team keeps discussing the same problem, but no genuinely new options are emerging - the same ideas keep coming back. 

Bring one real, specific problem - one that can actually generate options. 

Good: “How do we reduce onboarding time by 30%?” · “How do we meet the deadline after losing two people?” · “How do we cut customer complaints without adding headcount?” 

Avoid: “Improve performance” · “Be more innovative” · “Grow the business” - too broad to generate real options. 

What you get

  • Two or three genuinely new options that weren’t on the table before 
  • Proof of which ones your starting view would never have reached 
  • For each one, the viewpoint that unlocked it 

You have done it well when: the team can see that its freshest new option came from a viewpoint nobody would naturally have taken - and realises it was never short of ideas, just stuck in one frame. 

What you’ll notice

  • The same problem looks different from each viewpoint 
  • The strangest viewpoints often produce the sharpest ideas 
  • Fresh options appear surprisingly quickly 

Why this works

We get fixed on one way of seeing a problem, and then keep producing the same options - the fresh ideas go missing. Arguing as someone else removes the personal risk of being wrong, and an unexpected viewpoint breaks the pattern, so new options surface.

What you need

Everything comes in one kit. Here is each piece, and when you use it: 

The board   On which the viewpoint cards are placed. 

Problem card   The blank card on which the team’s problem is written and placed at the centre of the board. 

Six core viewpoint cards   customer, competitor, new joiner, maintainer, budget holder and outsider. The front names the viewpoint; the back contains a question to argue from. 

Eight hidden viewpoint cards   Surprise viewpoints the team won’t know in advance. 

Twist cards   Short cards in three colours - a constraint, a clash between two viewpoints, or a pattern-break. 

Capture sheet   One sheet used by the facilitator to capture ideas and solutions that emerge. 

A timer   The facilitator uses it to start and end rounds. 

Roles 

Facilitator   Runs the activity. Lays out the board, captures the starting answers, moves the problem card, reveals the hidden cards, draws twists, and keeps time. Captures new options on the sheet - or nominates a scribe to write while they run the room. Does not participate in the discussion or suggest ideas. Intervenes only when needed. 

Team (3–6 people)   writes the starting answer, then argues the problem as the assigned viewpoint. Calls out new ideas for the capture sheet. 

Steps

  1. Set up (5 min).Team: appoint a facilitator who runs the activity using the Facilitator Guide. The facilitator sets up the board with the six core viewpoints around the edge.
  2. Write the problem (5-7 min). As a team, agree on the one real problem you are stuck on, write it on the blank card, and place it in the centre of the board. Keep it specific. (As each viewpoint is used, the facilitator moves this card to that station.)
  3. Write your answer first (3-4 min).To start, everyone privately writes the one idea or solution they’d recommend if the team had to decide right now. Set these aside, unread - you’ll come back to them at the end. 
  4. Argue from a viewpoint (5-8 min).The facilitator picks one viewpoint card and moves the problem to it. For five minutes, the team discusses the solution to the problem as that person - ask “If you were the customer, what would you do about this?” As ideas emerge, the facilitator records them on the capture sheet. You won’t use all six viewpoints - the facilitator chooses two or three in total, mixing core and hidden. 
  5. Draw a hidden viewpoint (5-8 min). For at least one round, the facilitator picks a card from the face-down deck and opens it - a hidden viewpoint could be a regulator, a future customer, or someone from a very different world. Argue the problem from this viewpoint. 
  6. Add a twist (5-8 min). If the activity starts to feel predictable, the facilitator may draw a twist card and run the next round using it.
  7. Compare and reveal (5–7 min).The facilitator reads out the ideas and solutions everyone wrote at the start. Then they read the new options on the sheet. Ask: which of these would never have come from where we started? Pick the two or three freshest, and note which viewpoint unlocked each.
  8. Carry it forward (5 min). Circle the two or three freshest options worth exploring further - the ones to take into the real decision. The facilitator photographs the final capture sheet and shares it with the team.

Output / Takeaways

  • Two or three fresh options to evaluate further - carried into the real decision 
  • The viewpoint that unlocked each one 
  • A captured sheet that shows which options your starting view would never have reached 

Where this sits: Break the Frame opens up fresh options when thinking is stuck. If the team cannot agree on which option comes first, run Prioritise Under Pressure. If the problem rests on a shaky assumption, run Assumption Breaker. 

Important rules

  • Bring a real, stuck problem - not a hypothetical one 
  • Write your own answer first - before any viewpoint work 
  • Argue as the viewpoint - not as yourself 
  • Don’t look ahead in the hidden deck - the surprise does the work 
  • Write every new idea down - the sheet is the proof 

Planning to facilitate this activity? Access the resources below to get started.

MIndn
Execution must be smooth. Not chaotic or stressful.
Built by Witmer.