The Real Yes

Coming Soon

The Real Yes

1 · What this fixes 

Find out what people really think - and what the plan needs to hold. 

Your team agrees a deadline. Everyone says yes. Then the work starts, the date slips, and someone finally says they never thought you would make it. 

Nobody lied. The meeting made it easier to say yes than to raise a doubt. 

This surfaces the doubts before the work starts, and turns them into conditions the team can act on. An untested yes is the one that slips. 

2 · How this works 

Most teams ask the room whether everyone is happy. This asks everyone privately: 

How sure are you that we will deliver this as planned? 

Everyone answers 1 to 5 and reveals at the same time. The differences show where the plan needs testing. 

Then everyone writes privately - this commitment holds if, and this commitment breaks if. The team groups the conditions, decides what to do about each one, and commits again. 

You end with a commitment that has its conditions, risks and owners in the open. 

3 · Time required 

Solo ✗   Team ✓   About 25 to 35 minutes. 

Run it inside a meeting you already have, just before an important commitment is final. The facilitator reads the guide first - about six minutes, downloadable on this page. 

4 · When to use 

Use this when: 

  • you are about to commit to an important deadline or deliverable 
  • everyone agrees, but you are not sure everyone believes the plan 
  • plans have slipped before, despite everyone agreeing 
  • several people depend on each other to deliver 

Use it before the work starts - not once the problem is already running. 

5 · What you get 

  • A confidence reading for the plan, from the whole team 
  • The conditions the plan depends on, and what could break it 
  • A decision on every condition, with an owner 
  • Each commitment restated as “yes, provided --” 

You have done it well when the team can say: we will deliver this, it holds if that stays true, and we change course if this happens - and every condition has a decision. 

6 · What you’ll notice 

  • People say what they were holding back 
  • How many easy yeses were really just the meeting ending 
  • That the same condition often sits under several people’s doubts 

7 · Why this works 

People will say privately what they will not say first in a room. Revealing together stops the first confident answer shaping everyone else’s. Asking for conditions then turns a hidden doubt into something the team can act on. 

This does not ask anyone to disagree. It makes disagreement safe enough to surface. (Based on research into group decision-making.) 

8 · What you need 

  • Five confidence cards per person, numbered 1 to 5 
  • One condition slip per person, and a pen each 
  • One commitment record for the facilitator 
  • A real commitment the team is about to make - not a hypothetical 

No cards? People can hold up fingers under the table and show together. It works the same way. 

9 · Steps 

  1. State the commitment

The facilitator reads the exact commitment, with the date and the scope, and writes it at the top of the record. 

We will deliver these six items by 30 September, with the people we have now. 

  1. Rate confidence privately

Everyone picks a card, 1 to 5, and keeps it hidden. One question: how sure are you that we will deliver this as planned? 

  1. Reveal together

The facilitator counts to three. Everyone shows at the same time. Do not explain the numbers yet, and do not ask anyone to. 

  1. Write the conditions

Everyone writes privately, whatever number they held - what must stay true for this to hold, and what would break it. 

  1. Surface and group

The facilitator reads them out without names and groups the ones that repeat. Holding conditions first, breaking conditions second. Do not debate yet - make the full picture visible. 

  1. Decide what to do

Every condition ends in one of four outcomes: 

  • Fix it - an owner and a date 
  • Assign an owner to watch it 
  • Change the plan - move the date or cut the scope 
  • Accept it - go ahead knowing the risk 

A condition that reaches none of these stays on the record, marked untested. 

  1. Say yes again

Each person restates their commitment out loud: 

We will deliver --. We believe this is achievable because --. We need -- to stay true. We will change course if -- happens. 

The facilitator records each one, photographs the record, and sends it before anyone leaves. 

10 · Output / Takeaways 

One commitment record, carrying: 

  • Our commitment - what we will deliver 
  • Confidence - how sure the team is 
  • Conditions - what must hold 
  • Risks - what could break it 
  • Decisions and owners - what we will do, and who 

11 · Important rules 

  • Vote privately. Reveal together. 
  • Never ask someone to defend their number. 
  • Test the commitment, never the person. 
  • Capture the conditions before debating any of them. 
  • Every condition gets a decision before the plan is final. 
  • Do not leave the room with a bare yes. 

Planning to facilitate this activity? Access the resources below to get started.

MIndn
Execution must be smooth. Not chaotic or stressful.
Built by Witmer.