A vague brief arrives - “make the dashboard better”, “modernise onboarding”, “look into churn” - and the team starts building before pinning down what’s actually being asked. Each person quietly starts solving a different problem, the work goes in different directions, and no one notices until it’s late. The problem isn’t that someone misread the brief; it’s that the brief had several workable readings and the team never chose one.
A vague brief is not the problem. Acting on it too early is.
Three people get the brief “improve the onboarding flow”. One sets out to cut the number of steps, one to fix the confusing copy, one to add a guided tour. All three are reasonable - and all three are different problems. They were never going to build the same thing, and no one had spotted it.
Each person writes the problem they think the brief is asking them to solve. The readings are compared side by side, the team chooses one, and sharpens it into a concrete problem everyone will work from.
Team: one person runs the activity using the Facilitator Guide. The people who’ll act on the brief take part.
Team ✓
Team: 45–60 minutes, with a facilitator.
The time required is indicative and will depend on the nature of the problem and the size of the team.
The facilitator must read the short facilitation guide first - about 8–10 minutes. It is a downloadable PDF on this page.
Bring a real brief you’re about to act on - vague enough that you’re not certain what it’s asking.
Use it whenever:
One workable problem the whole team can act on.
You’ve done it well when: the team has a single, concrete problem it can act on - specific enough that no two people could read it differently.
A vague brief allows several reasonable readings of the same words. People fill the gaps in an ambiguous ask with their own reading, so a team can start confidently and still be building different things. Surfacing the readings makes the difference visible, and choosing one concrete problem is what lets the work converge.
Everything comes in one kit. Here is each part, and when you use it:
Interpretation cards (core). Blank, write-on cards. Each person writes the problem they think the brief is asking them to solve. These are what you compare.
The comparison board. A board where every reading is laid out side by side, so the different problems hiding in the brief are visible at a glance.
Sharpening prompt cards. Prompts that turn a chosen reading into a concrete, workable problem - who it’s for, what changes, what “done” looks like. Used when the team converges on one problem.
Starter-brief cards (optional). Example vague briefs. Use one only if the group has no real brief of its own to work on. Otherwise, set them aside.
Roles - Team: a facilitator (runs the flow, keeps interpretation private until the reveal, holds the team to one concrete problem) and participants (interpret the brief, compare readings, build the problem).
Output / Takeaways
Important rules
Planning to facilitate this activity? Access the resources below to get started.